For as long as pollsters have been asking Americans about religion, women have been more devout than men. They’ve been more likely to attend church and to pray, and less likely to walk away from the faith they were raised in. That isn’t true anymore. According to research to the Survey Center on American Life, 39 percent of Generation Z women now say they have no religious affiliation, compared with 34 percent of Gen Z men. Among young adults who are not part of a religious tradition, 54 percent are women. Among Baby Boomers, just 43 percent are.
When much of American Christianity has been taken over by patriarchal reactionaries, it’s not surprising that so many Gen Z women have walked away. Nearly two-thirds of young women say that churches don’t treat men and women equally. And the far-right crusades against reproductive rights and LGBTQ people are obviously harming the Christian brand as well. Prominent pastors and right-wing influencers are even arguing that women shouldn’t be allowed to vote.
Beyond the politics though, when it comes to women, white evangelicals pastors abandon their “bootstraps” language and tell them to embrace dependency — but only on men. Right wing political organizations like Turning Point USA echo this message as well, teaching members get married young, have more children than they can afford, and let their husbands be in charge. Submit to God and to men, always be positive, and banish religious doubt, and you’ll be rewarded with both heavenly and earthly blessings.
And it wasn’t just men who were offering this Faustian bargain. Many conservative Christian women have built enormous careers selling dependency and repression through bestselling books, conferences, radio, and home goods.
While these toxic messages are finally getting some media and scholarly attention, they are anything but new. And my guest today is very qualified to talk about how this all got started. Kristin Kobes Du Mez wrote the best-selling book Jesus and John Wayne several years ago and she’s out with a new one looking at the other side of white Christian patriarchy. This one is called Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made.
The video and transcript of our conversation are below, including audio chapters for your convenience. You can subscribe to Theory of Change and other Flux podcasts on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Podcasts, YouTube, and elsewhere. You can become a paid or free subscriber on Patreon or Substack, and also support the show on GoFundMe.
Related Content
MAGA is morphing beyond a political identity into a sexual fetish
How far-right Christian media brainwash evangelicals
The right-wing wars on science and sex are linked
Pleasure, pain, and why religion and science have justified women’s suffering
The women of QAnon
As evangelicalism grows increasingly unhinged, where is Mormonism going?
‘Left Behind’ and the nihilism of modern Protestant fundamentalism
Audio Chapters
00:00 — Introduction
05:56 — How culture carries ideas to people who don’t read theology or philosophy
09:06 — Reactionary Christian women’s paradoxical relationship to patriarchal theology
19:29 — Positive thinking, prosperity theology, and Donald Trump
30:29 — Christian nationalism and the promise of divine reward
35:23 — Fascinating Womanhood and the selling of submission
44:25 — Little House on the Prairie and the libertarian frontier myth
50:49 — Wholesome nostalgia, trad wives, and racial politics
56:22 — How Christian media made conservatism the default
01:02:30 — Women who challenged evangelical gatekeepers—and why young women leave
01:10:53 — Demographic decline and the turn against democracy
01:15:51 — Finding a way out of systems of control
Audio Transcript
The following is a lightly edited transcription of the discussion.
MATTHEW SHEFFIELD: We’ve wanted to do a podcast together for a long time, and now we’re finally doing it, so I’m really glad for it. And it’s a great occasion, because you’ve got another really interesting and important book.
This one grew out of your previous one. So why don’t we start from there?
KRISTIN KOBES DU MEZ: Sure. So six years ago now in 2020, I published Jesus and John Wayne: How White Evangelicals Corrupted a Faith and Fractured a Nation. [00:04:00] And that was a book that essentially looked at white evangelical ideals of masculinity intertwined with militarism and Christian nationalism. And it was a book that exploded in part because it showed how evangelical support for Donald Trump and the broader MAGA agenda was not an aberration.
It was not a betrayal of their values. It instead showed that there was this underlying commitment to militarism and to a militant conception of Christian manhood, that violence would be necessary to bring order and power was what was ultimately valued to defeat all the enemies, domestic and foreign.
And so that book really took off not only as a kind of window onto American political culture, but also inside evangelical communities. Thousands of evangelical readers have written to me over the years saying, “This is the story of my life,” because it looked not just at what prominent leaders were teaching, but also at evangelical popular culture, the books that sold tens of millions of copies that line people’s bookshelves, Christian radio, those sorts of things.
So Live, Laugh, Love is essentially the next chapter in that story. Rather than looking at ideals of masculinity, it looks at the flip side. It looks at ideals of white Christian womanhood, particularly looking at popular cultural products, Christian romance novels, influencer spaces, Christian music, and Christian home decor, and examines what political and economic values are embedded within those products that help us understand their political allegiances today.
How culture carries ideas to people who don’t read theology or philosophy
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and one thing I really like about [00:06:00] your approach is that I think probably most historians have a serious problem focusing on intellectuals. And so they will write a book that says, “Okay, here are profiles of these five people, and they were so influential.”
And these are people no one in their time period had heard of. And that’s just not how life is. And of course, this is a podcast for intellectuals, so ironically, it is self-aware. And it’s not that these ideas and books are unimportant.
Of course they are, but they’re not how most people have contact with ideas.
DU MEZ: Exactly. And I make the case that this is especially true for Christian women, and that women are often kept out of positions of authority, particularly in conservative religious traditions. They do not go to seminary and study theology at the same rates as men do.
They do not usually stand behind important pulpits, and they aren’t creating this elite intellectual life or, to a large part, consuming that. Instead, Christian women may be listening to eight to 10 hours of Christian radio a day. They’re shopping in Christian bookstores.
They’re reading daily devotionals that are produced specifically for them, often with pink floral covers. This kind of popular level of religion is so powerful, and that’s what I wanted to focus on. Now, one important difference between Live, Laugh, Love and Jesus and John Wayne is actually pointed to in the subtitle.
Live, Laugh, Love is the [00:08:00] Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. So this is a broader story than just evangelicals. It does look at evangelical women and charismatic women and mainline Protestant women, but it also centers Mormon women as a key part of the story, and it actually also adds a secular tradition of positive thinking, where this idea of positivity takes hold.
And it shows how in popular Christian women’s culture, in popular white women’s culture, spaces like Hallmark movies, Hobby Lobby, Joanna Gaines’ Magnolia, all of these strands actually come together to produce a culture that just hundreds of millions of women consume every day. And the power of this culture is that the values embedded within it do not seem political.
This is just entertainment. These are just devotionals. This is... But in fact, these products powerfully shape the political convictions of millions of American women.
Reactionary Christian women’s paradoxical relationship to patriarchal theology
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. And that’s a really important point. And we’ll hopefully be able to touch on this throughout the conversation here today, but one of the things about that dynamic that you’re talking about is that it’s a culture that grew up through being oppressed and kept down.
And so part of what their underlying, culture of mores is about how do we continue when not having power? How do we continue despite feeling bad about our place in society? And that’s actually something that’s positive about the culture here because male culture never really got that.
And [00:10:00] now that we’re in a moment in time where the middle class, thanks to oligarchs like Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos and others, they are deliberately shrinking the middle class and disempowering the middle class. And so now you have a moment where many men are completely disempowered, because they can’t find a job.
They live in a place where there are no opportunities and there’s no one to tell them, to help them understand what to do. And then on top of that the male culture never developed a resilience subtext. Hopefully we can talk about how these different women we’re discussing today were able to...
DU MEZ: Yeah. I think that’s true, that the women that I write about, women in Christian spaces and in conservative spaces, had to figure out what power looked like when they inhabited systems that privileged male authority, and privileged that authority as God-ordained, and taught women that the path to their power was through giving up power.
So there’s always this paradox: if you submit to men, if you submit to your husband, to your pastor, if you show deference to them—and this is really important here, so I’m not sure that this is a great model to give to men today feeling that power is slipping away—and if you support the system, then you will be given power.
But it’s always conditional. You break any of these rules, then it will be taken from you. And so what we see over the course of the history that I write is that, over and over again, women are actually given positions of significant power. Women like Phyllis Schlafly, Anita Bryant, and, in evangelical spaces, Elisabeth Elliot.
You could see Sarah Palin, Erika Kirk, if you wanna bring it up to the present. But this is [00:12:00] always conditional power, and it’s always precarious power, and what is absolutely key is that they only use that power to support the system, otherwise it will be taken from them. So it is a constrained power, but within those constraints, women can exercise a lot of creativity and agency, and these conservative systems could not be perpetuated were it not for the agency of women on the inside.
They become the chief propagandists and promoters of these conservative ideologies.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah, exactly. Okay, well, you identify three different strands of that. So let’s start with the first major figure you focus on in the book, through the 1875 book The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life.
DU MEZ: Yeah, so the whole first chapter, I’m a historian, so I go deep into history ‘cause I’m trying to tease out the origins of this popular Christian women’s culture. I did not plan to start in the 19th century. But where I did start was in the 1960s and ‘70s, reading books by popular writers like Catherine Marshall, author of the novel Christy, Elisabeth Elliot, this evangelical missionary hero, and Marabel Morgan’s Total Woman, telling women how to be sexy and submit to their husbands.
These were massively bestselling authors and books. But what I noticed that every single one of them pointed back to this 19th century figure, Hannah Whitall Smith, the author of the book The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life. So I had to figure out why. And what I discovered was the secret, Hannah’s secret to a happy life, was total surrender of your will.
By totally surrendering your will to [00:14:00] God’s will, she promised that you could tap this immense spiritual power that would make you holy, even perfect. It would give you this absolute holiness, purity, perfection, and with that, the promise was that happiness would come. So you submit, you trust and obey, and you will be #blessed with happiness, with all the good things.
And this was such a tantalizing promise. That’s what Hannah Whitall Smith really established. Now, she herself was a feminist. She did not submit to her husband or to religious authorities who were men who said you shouldn’t be preaching. She had no time for that. But what we see is over the course of the 20th century, her theology morphs into, for women, submission, total submission, total surrender to the men in your life, the men that God has appointed over you.
That is the ticket to holiness, and with it happiness. And that’s really what we see bubbling up over the course of the 20th century, and really shaping ideas of what it means to be a good Christian woman, an obedient Christian woman, and it always comes with that promise. If you submit, if you obey, you’ll be blessed with all good things.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and then certainly things like that are stated within the Bible repeatedly. Certainly by Paul and many others. And the whole book of Philemon is about slaves, you should submit to your masters. So of course a woman should submit to her husband.
DU MEZ: Yeah. I will say that reading this, I’m reading about how you become holy. That’s called sanctification. So these teachings that you see taking hold, yes, there are Bible verses to support all of these. But what you see is this evolves not just into this kind of submission to men, but also through charismatic spaces, it evolves into prosperity gospel too.
This [00:16:00] simplistic formula. If you do this, all the good things are gonna come to you, spiritual and material. All. So it gives this neat formula. Now, if you expand that, you’ll also see in the Bible a whole lot of verses that counteract this. Because you also have verses that say, “In Christ there is neither male nor female.”
There’s a lot of verses that talk about to follow Christ is to divest oneself of power, not to claim power over others. There are verses about how it’s harder for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven than a camel to go through the eye of a needle. Which kinda goes against prosperity gospel teachings.
Which is to say, the Bible says a lot of things, and at various times in the history of Christianity, certain people pick certain Bible verses to hold up and form a whole ideology around. And to do so they often have to set aside other Bible verses. This is not surprising, but in conservative evangelical spaces, in fact, that’s not a widely held view when it comes to their own views.
They would say, “No, what we are saying is direct from God, direct from the Bible, and the only way to be a Christian,” and that’s the power of that theology.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and the other thing about Smith and many of the women that you talk about is that she herself did not practice these strict anti-feminist, ideals in her own life. And we see this over and over again, that the biggest, most famous proponents of “women, submit to men” don’t do that themselves.
DU MEZ: Very much. And so Smith, to her credit, she never said a woman submitting to God equals submitting to men. She actually saw men getting in her way of obeying God. That said, the promise of a happy life did not come true for [00:18:00] her at all. Several of her children died. Her husband was a total jerk.
He was having affairs. He was-- She was not about to submit to his authority, and by the end of her life, she knew it. And so the only way she could reconcile this deep disappointment with her lifelong attempt to be faithful was to actually redefine happiness itself. She concluded happiness isn’t actually a feeling.
Happiness, too, has to be an act of the will. And so you can see then the promise is ultimately empty, but it didn’t actually manifest in her own life. But you’re right. In the hands of others who believe, who preach that the way to be blessed is to submit to masculine authority, through the history of American conservatism, we see so many women who preach that or spread that teaching while actually holding leadership positions themselves.
It was the performativity that mattered most. And these conservative ideologies of femininity could not have been perpetuated were it not for women themselves being at the front lines promoting these to other women, teaching other women that this is the path to power. It’s a paradox, but if you follow these rules of submission, you too can have God-intended power.
It’s just gonna look very different from the power that feminists are talking about.
Positive thinking, prosperity theology, and Donald Trump
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and the contradictions in democracy get much worse as we continue. But then one of the other core principles behind this mentality. And again, I do wanna stress that it is important to be able to have resilience in an unjust world.
It’s very important. And sometimes in more socialist or, [00:20:00] anarchist left spaces, you often hear people, they don’t know how to live in the real world. And so they constantly say things, “Well, I don’t care about politics because it’s all gonna burn, and so I don’t vote.
I’m not gonna vote for somebody who is not 100%, Joseph Stalin,” or whatever.
DU MEZ: Right.
SHEFFIELD: And so you have to live... There are two fundamental questions, which are: What is justice? And then how do you live with injustice in society as it is?
DU MEZ: Exactly. That’s such a good point. And I will say another thing that conservatives have really excelled at, I think, and that has worked well for them, isn’t just, in some cases, this resilience, but also by embracing positivity. And I show how that works in conservative evangelical spaces through this particular kind of holiness theology.
Again, total submission, and then you’re going to be blessed. But total submission looks like erasing all doubts. Doubt is of the devil, and keeping a positive attitude. Now, this dovetails with a secular philosophy that we see emerging in the 19th century and running through up to the present, which we call the philosophy of positive thinking.
Think Norman Vincent Peale. He brings it into Christian spaces, but it’s a largely secular philosophy with roots in 19th-century New Thought. Now, both of these things say a positive attitude is absolutely necessary, and if you keep that positive attitude and don’t have doubts, get rid of criticisms, especially criticisms of the powers that be, of the structural systems, then good things will happen to you.
This is the foundation of the get-rich-quick manuals that are all over the place in the 20th century and even up to today. Like Napoleon Hill’s Think and Grow Rich. Think prosperity thoughts, you’re going to be prosperous. This is the logic behind MLMs, multilevel marketing, and that [00:22:00] philosophy.
Get rid of all doubts. Believe that this will work for you and it will. Now, what this does is, on the one hand, it’s a very individualistic ethos, but it is empowering in the short term for people who buy into it who say, “You know what? The world might be against me, but it doesn’t matter, ‘cause I can still get out of bed in the morning, and I can change my own circumstances simply by changing my attitude.”
So it is enticing, and all things being equal, you’re probably going to accomplish more if you get out of bed in the morning with that attitude rather than, “There’s nothing I can do. Why even try?” Now, of course, the pernicious part of this is that this ideology puts everything on the mind of the individual, which means there is no systemic inequality that is real.
There is no such thing as structural racism that gets in the way of any one person’s ability to succeed. All you have to do is think the right way. Work hard and success will follow. So this, not surprisingly, ends up being an ideology that is perfectly suited to free market capitalism, and it’s no coincidence that you have powerful corporate interests funding organizations and individuals who are promoting this version of Christianity or this version of Americanism because it plays into their hands.
No need for New Deal liberalism, no need for social welfare. In fact, those things actually get in the way of this individualistic ethos, and every person has the power within themselves to succeed if only they try hard enough.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and these ideas are also the root of the modern-day prosperity gospel movement as well. And then there’s a direct connection to Donald Trump with this through Norman Vincent Peale. So let’s talk about that.
DU MEZ: Yeah. As a young boy, Trump’s dad, Fred Trump, who was making a [00:24:00] ton of money in real estate at the time, would drive his family into Manhattan so they could sit in the pews at Marble Collegiate every Sunday and listen to Norman Vincent Peale preach this gospel of positivity.
It all came down to positive thinking. And Donald Trump has talked about how mesmerizing Peale’s sermons were, and he just... If you wanna understand Donald Trump and all of his lies and his boasting and his seeming disconnect from reality, a lot of that...
There are probably some psychological reasons for some of that, but it also is consistent with this philosophy of positive thinking.
If you just believe, if you say it, it will come true. And so you can deny reality and have power to shape your own reality, and he sure has found a way to manifest and to hold incredible power. Now, the other thing to know about this ideology, this theology, is that what it ends up doing is essentially baptizing wealth and power.
Because if you are wealthy and powerful, clearly you did something right, ‘cause that’s how this is supposed to work. And the flip side is if you’re poor, if you’re marginalized, clearly it’s on you, ‘cause everybody has within themself the power to succeed. So this is the perfect theology, philosophy, ideology, if you will, for Donald Trump because it just constantly justifies his own power and gives him permission to ignore reality, manifest what it is that he wants, and deny everything that contradicts it.
And if you look at some of his rhetoric on the Iran war, on the [00:26:00] economy, on pretty much anything, it starts to make a whole lot more sense within this framework.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah, absolutely. And the other thing also about this mentality and the subsequent people as well, is that it moves moral responsibility from society to the individual. And so if you have problems in your life, not only is it your fault, but it’s also not the responsibility of society to help you.
Society has no responsibility to you at all. Everyone is out for themselves, and the government is out for itself as well. And of course, that’s one of the other things about the second Trump term and constantly grifting off of his people and using the government to enrich himself.
This is exactly what they tell you to do.
DU MEZ: Right, exactly. And one of the central themes of Live, Laugh, Love is really how much of this popular Christian culture, including that which is marketed to women specifically, is designed to push back against social justice Christianity and New Deal liberalism, and the idea that there is a common good that we should invest in and that the government should protect.
Instead, the government’s role gets completely morphed into protecting big business. So pushing back against labor, pushing back against any Christians who teach social justice theology, the social gospel. That has to be destroyed, and instead funding and fueling conservative economic theologies essentially, which do exactly this.
So the government’s role is to get out of the way of big business, no regulations, and just enable those who are wealthy to gain more [00:28:00] wealth and saying that this is the way that God has ordained society to operate.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and also the moral discussions that are allowed to happen, they move from being, “These things are bad in our society,” to, “I have to confess I did these bad things.” And so there’s this constant obsession with reading things and saying, “Oh, I’m terrible at this thing here.
I did this sin here. This is why I have these problems in my life, and I need to confess my sins constantly, because that’s the only way to overcome them and to have blessings.”
DU MEZ: Yep, there’s the idea that sin is something that blocks you from accessing divine power. But when that divine power flows through you, whether it’s the Christian God or just the divine in more secular spaces, sin is anything that blocks that channel of power.
But when you can open that channel of power, all the good things are gonna happen. You’re going to be holy. You’re gonna be perfect. You’re going to be powerful. You’re going to be rich. And then confession has this role, as you suggest, of individually and one-on-one and in small groups, you’re supposed to confess all of those things that are blocking that access to this divine power.
And so if things aren’t working out for you, yes, it is always on you. You have to figure out, were you not believing hard enough? Were you not working hard enough for your multilevel marketing company? Were you not submitting hard enough, if you are a woman? ‘Cause women have the extra burden of not just staying positive and pure, but also their power [00:30:00] comes through submission, and so did you submit hard enough?
And if things still aren’t working for you, it is always on you. So buy another book, listen to another podcast, and submit harder, believe harder. And it really is a perfect system because the system itself can never be blamed because even the very act of questioning the system is itself defined as sin.
So it is a perfect system for controlling people.
Christian nationalism and the promise of divine reward
SHEFFIELD: Yeah, it really is. It’s a definition of circular reasoning and unfalsifiability.
Well, another interesting thing about this perspective is that it is political as well. With regard to abortion, and when homosexuality was in the process of becoming destigmatized, there were a lot of people who were out there saying things like, “Well, the reason why the economy is bad is because we allow abortion.” Or, “The reason...” And Jerry Falwell, and others like him were always saying things like, “Well, the reason this natural disaster happened was because God is punishing you for not imprisoning people who are gay.”
And so it’s not just a personal moral viewpoint. It’s also a political standpoint in that if you are morally righteous and live the way that we say you should, then you will have a great economy too, not just wealth in your own life.
DU MEZ: That is exactly true, and this is one of the key logics of Christian nationalism. Christian nationalism is a term that we use today to describe essentially this idea that all of America, all Americans need to be brought into obedience with [00:32:00] God’s law as they understand it in a fundamentalist sense.
But the idea here is that this is ultimately for your own good. Yes, you will be punished. Yes, you’ll be coerced. But ultimately, if and when you do align with God’s will for your life, and we’ll give you all the commandments here, but love your neighbor as yourself and love your enemies are not on that list.
It’s more a harsh, very selective use of the Old Testament. Essentially, God’s order aligns very closely with the MAGA agenda. And so if you follow all of these rules, then you are gonna be blessed by God, and we as a country are going to be blessed by God. But if we fail, if we conservative Christians fail to bring our country under God’s control, then we as a country will be punished.
That’s what you hear from Jerry Falwell. That’s what you hear over and over again in these Christian nationalist spaces. So that gives them this sense that, well, we’re actually doing everybody a favor, even if you’re fighting against us. By enforcing these rules, ultimately, this is going to restore Christian America.
And when we restore Christian America, when we as a country bring our laws in alignment with God’s laws and coerce obedience, we will all be blessed by God instead of being punished by hurricanes or whatever goes wrong. And that’s the logic that makes them feel like, no, we’re actually passing these coercive laws and stripping your constitutional rights, but it’s gonna ultimately be for your own good.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and that idea developed further into the 1950s and ‘60s. And it did so through a group of people that had been marginalized and excluded from American [00:34:00] society, and that is the Mormons. The Mormons were so hated and despised that they literally left the country and went to Mexico, which is what Utah was part of back then.
And did their own thing, and of course, a lot of that was involving polygyny or polygamy as people call it. But then eventually they got rid of that practice and really embraced the... In a lot of ways, Mormonism is the original Christian nationalism in a lot of senses, in that it was a more mature systematized Christian nationalism.
These ideas were there before them, but they really weren’t written down. And now you have the Book of Mormon where America is in the scriptures.
America is in the scriptures and God says, “Whoever lives in this hemisphere,” as they believed it back then, “must obey Christianity. And if you do, then God will bless you.” So this was the perfect instantiation for this mentality. So you didn’t even have to believe the Mormons. If you heard about it but you knew, well, they were in favor of America. They love America, and so therefore this is a good book.
And that takes us to Helen Andelin.
Fascinating Womanhood and the selling of submission
DU MEZ: Yes. Yeah, you’re exactly right. We see this kind of shift, too, in Mormonism’s identity. From these outsiders, immoral outsiders, polygamous outsiders, anti-American outsiders, ‘cause despite what Mormons themselves taught, they were perceived as just beyond the pale.
But by mid-century, they start to move closer to the center of American values. They rebrand. They embrace free market capitalism, and set aside some of their historic collectivism. They become [00:36:00] increasingly aligned with conservative evangelicalism in a number of different ways, and you see these transformations take hold, and it accomplishes what they set out for, which is that they have greater influence on mainstream American culture.
But yes, I have a whole chapter on Helen Andelin in Live, Laugh, Love, and she is such an interesting figure. Helen Andelin writes a book called Fascinating Womanhood in 1963. So 1963, by the way, the same year Betty Friedan writes The Feminine Mystique, which really jumpstarts the modern feminist movement.
And Andelin offers a counterpoint, a guide to obedient Christian femininity. And to be a successful Christian wife and woman, it’s the opposite of feminism. You do not assert your rights, not at all. You just revel in your dependency on men. Your power comes by giving up all rights, and giving up all conventional power, and submitting yourself to your husband, catering to his every need and desire.
And when you make your husband happy, you too will be happy because he’ll give you good things. He’ll take you on vacation, give you rose bushes, and a refrigerator, and that’s really the key to happiness. And so what’s really interesting is both she and Friedan are speaking to a generation of unhappy women.
They’re unhappy with their lot in life. They’re in unhappy homes. They are frustrated and unfulfilled, but they offer these polar opposite recommendations. Either you go out and get a career, and assert your independence, and claim your rights for Friedan, or you give up all idea of rights.
You just change your attitude. You change yourself, and then the promise is when you do this, good things are going to happen to you. Now, that’s [00:38:00] Helen Andelin’s story. That book goes on to sell more than three million copies. Her daughter actually claims it’s closer to five million. Influential particularly in Mormon spaces, it also spills over into American culture.
But it also ends up informing and really inspiring, directly inspiring a book published a decade later by Marabel Morgan called The Total Woman. This takes all of Andelin’s ideas, packages it for an evangelical audience, and The Total Woman becomes the best-selling book in America, nonfiction book in 1974, sells more than ten million copies, and provides the template for Christian womanhood essentially from that time forward.
So it’s this profoundly influential book that comes from a Mormon. But it turns out Helen Andelin actually borrowed her ideas to write Fascinating Womanhood from a set of booklets published in the 1920s, also called Fascinating Womanhood, and that was published by Psychology Press, a New Thought publisher, essentially the philosophy of positive thinking, which all makes sense.
It’s all about attitude, not your circumstances. And for women to attract a man is the key to success. This is based on the law of attraction. If you are attractive, beautiful, feminine, frilly, you will attract good things and have all the good things given to you. So it’s pretty wild that we see here all of these threads connecting.
New Thought, positive thinking, being embraced by a Mormon woman, and then in turn by evangelicalism, and that’s why it’s so easy for women to move back and forth between these traditions and to consume products produced in each of these spaces. Think of modern trad-wife influencers and women bloggers.
Think about multilevel marketing, which draws on all of these strands founded by [00:40:00] evangelicals or Mormons. They all look very similar because they’re all drawing essentially on the same philosophy.
SHEFFIELD: They were. And just as an interesting comparative point, The Feminine Mystique, it took until the year 2000 for it to have sold... Again, to my point at the top of the episode, there’s a tendency among a lot of especially highly educated left-oriented people to think, “Oh, well this is just crap.
These books are crap. Doesn’t matter what they say. I’m not gonna waste my time looking at this bullshit or thinking about it because who cares? It’s irrelevant nonsense.” Well, guess what? Your stuff is irrelevant. It’s not... Or this idea, “Well, we are platforming people by talking about them.”
And it’s like they’re really popular, probably more popular than you, so you’re not platforming.
DU MEZ: Totally. And I think to be fair, it’s worth going back in time and imagine yourself as one of those unhappy housewives in the ‘60s or ‘70s, and you have these two options in front of you. And Friedan says, “Hey, there’s an escape for you. Go get a career.
Not just a job, a meaningful career. Assert your rights. You can do this.” But imagine you maybe have three or four kids by that point in time. You maybe have a high school education, but nothing beyond that. You have no real job experience. Is that actually helpful? Is that going to liberate you?
It’s just unfeasible. And then here comes Helen Andelin or Marabel Morgan, and they say, “You just have to change your attitude. Just cater to your husband’s every need. Make him happy, and when he is happy, he will make you happy.” And what is more achievable? For [00:42:00] many women, they chose the second option, and that was where they invested, and that’s where they tried to improve their lot in life because frankly, it was the only feasible option.
And then imagine you are in a conservative church community, whether Mormon or evangelical. And the second option really does seem to align more closely with your religious values, and that’s why so many millions of women chose that path instead of the path of feminist liberation.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, it’s, it is easier in some senses. It really is. Like if you’re okay with being told what to do all the time, or at least pretending to accept that,
DU MEZ: Pretending. Yeah.
SHEFFIELD: And that’s one of the other things about these books is about, well, you let him think that he has control over you, but actually you can manipulate him and here are 20 different ways to manipulate your man.
So in a certain sense, it is easier. But it’s a toxic foundation of a relationship because if the only reason that a woman is in a relationship is because she wants money,
Then if the man loses his money or for whatever reason, they have financial problems or whatever, then the foundation of their relationship is gone.
And it’s not a mutual respect, a mutual duty, a mutual care. It’s simply a transaction.
DU MEZ: Yeah, and another obvious limitation here is that not every problem can be fixed with a positive attitude. And so what if you find yourself in an abusive marriage? What if you’re married to a total jerk who no matter how nice you are to him, no matter how much you give him what he demands, he still treats you like dirt?
What recourse do you have? Within these systems, none. The only solution is [00:44:00] to fix yourself better. Become more submissive. And obviously you can see how this ends up trapping some women in abusive relationships where they cannot even identify what is happening to them as abuse, because they have not even been given the framework that allows them to see that.
All they know is if they are not happy, it is their own fault and they need to fix themselves.
Little House on the Prairie and the libertarian frontier myth
SHEFFIELD: Yeah, exactly. Well, and another way of creating this culture is the promulgation of the ideal frontier woman. And of course that exists even now today. But it did have a starting point and it really, was for many people, including a lot of people that I know, through the Little House on the Prairie novel, or well, no, they’re basically novels,
Of Rose Wilder Lane.
And nowadays the books, they really rapidly faded away, even within right-wing spaces now. Like, I don’t see them talked about very much and there aren’t any-- Like, there isn’t... There was a TV show of it that was very popular. But now, there hasn’t been a remake of it and you would think that they would have tried to do that again.
But they haven’t. Who knows why that has happened, but it was influential back in...
DU MEZ: So we did...
SHEFFIELD: For those who don’t know, tell us.
DU MEZ: Yeah, we did actually have a remake on Netflix this summer.
SHEFFIELD: Oh, did they? Oh, wow. See, I need to...
DU MEZ: Yeah, so I’ll tell you about that in a little bit, but first let’s go back to the deeper history. So yes, this whole frontier individualism, I talk in the book briefly about again, I’m a historian—19th-century Frederick Jackson Turner and his frontier myth, which was really influential in the early 20th century to remake American identity around this idea of the frontier.
The frontier was [00:46:00] what set America apart from European countries and it rewarded individualism and hard work, and this was the spirit of America, really. And then Laura Ingalls Wilder ends up taking essentially some of the pieces of that and then popularizing them through her Little House series.
But what a lot of people don’t know is that before she wrote the first Little House in the Big Woods book, she wrote an autobiography called Pioneer Girl, and she couldn’t get it published. It wasn’t exciting enough. And so her daughter, Rose Wilder Lane, comes along and helps her because one of the editors who rejected it suggested, “Well, if you take parts of this and turn it into a book for children, for young readers, it might have some potential.”
Rose Wilder Lane was herself a journalist—”journalist” loosely defined. She played fast and loose with facts. She knew how to tell a really good story. Rose Wilder Lane was also deeply political, and over the course of the ‘30s and ‘40s became one of America’s leading libertarians.
And what she did with her mom, who also shared her political views, even if not quite so extreme, she helped her mom rewrite her story into the Little House series. And when she did that, she injected these libertarian values into the storylines. So government is always bad, it’s evil. Anybody can succeed if only they are good, and responsible, and try hard enough.
And what she ended up doing then, because we have that initial autobiography to compare against the fictional series, is she erased all parts of the story that contradicted this libertarian narrative, and enhanced or even made up facts—quote-unquote “facts”—that supported [00:48:00] this.
And so the whole series is really designed to instill these values, and she was very clear in talking to her mom that the books were supposed to convey deeper moral truths. And so the more that both of them worked these deeper moral truths, economic truths into the books, the more they insisted, “Oh, no, these are totally true.
These are totally factual,” even though they’re published as children’s novels. So what the Little House series ends up doing is instilling a really powerful sense of identity, and that identity was individualistic and libertarian leaning. Now, in terms of its popularity, my goodness, I don’t know how many millions of copies those books sold.
It did inspire the television show in the 1970s, which was Ronald Reagan’s favorite television show. He’d watch it Monday nights in the White House. And I don’t think it went away as much as you think it did. It depends what spaces you’re looking at, because in Christian spaces, in conservative Christian spaces, these books have remained very popular.
They are wholesome, they are patriotic, and they are just rooted in this kind of an old-time American identity when things were right with the world, when people had strong values, and they would go to church on Sunday, and they would pray before dinner. And so in conservative spaces, those books have remained popular.
Now, there was a remake that came out this summer that got some attention because it was critiqued by some conservatives as having gone woke, and there’s actually some truth to that. One example that was given was that one of the main characters in the first season is a Black doctor. Now, in fact, that is historically accurate, but conservatives had forgotten that part, so they thought that was totally woke, but no, that was actually [00:50:00] historically accurate.
But it is true, ‘cause I watched it with this kind of critical lens and knowing the history of Little House, the director made some deliberate choices to actually undermine the thesis of individualism and libertarianism. And throughout, it not only complicates in very helpful ways the relationship between white settlers and Native Americans, and humanizes the Native Americans, but also demonstrates how the settlers themselves were absolutely relying on the federal government to clear the land, to go back on treaties with Native Americans, to build the railroads, to fund the schools, these sorts of things.
SHEFFIELD: And to give them the land.
DU MEZ: What’s that?
SHEFFIELD: And to give them the land for no money.
Wholesome nostalgia, trad wives, and racial politics
DU MEZ: Huge. So the government actually, it plays a much more visible role than in the novels. Now, Rose Wilder Lane, with Ayn Rand, helped start the modern libertarian movement, and had a profound influence on American conservatism in the post-World War II era.
And what we can see is that millions of Americans were, unknown to them, immersed in this value system. And so there’s a quote I include in the book, getting back to Ronald Reagan, where I talk about his victory in 1980, and how he somehow appealed to this conservative populism and libertarianism and that was a feeling that Americans just somehow had deep in their bones, that this is what it is to be American.
And one of the arguments I make is the Little House series, and then the books that they inspired, including books on prairie fiction in Christian publishing, were part of what helped put those feelings in people’s bones. This deep sense of what it [00:52:00] is to be an American, and it certainly doesn’t look like New Deal liberalism.
SHEFFIELD: No. Yeah, and this desire and undercurrent exist even now. A lot of the trad-wife content really does try to recreate this same sensibility and visual aesthetic. Because, again, they’re trying to say, “Well, this is back when people took care of themselves and didn’t want anyone to help them.”
And the other interesting thing about it is that they don’t think that these ideas are political. They really do not.
DU MEZ: Yes. That is how they are so effective. And especially if you’re looking at products that are marketed to women, that are designed for women. This is just wholesome. This is just pure. This is just patriotic. This is just who we are as Americans.
And yet these products are just deeply political, and they’re so powerfully political precisely because they do not appear to be so. So people aren’t approaching them with a critical lens of what are the values here? Do I personally agree with them? Do these values align with my personal values?
It’s much more subtle and therefore much more powerful than that. But the whole prairie aesthetic is really having a moment again, and I think that’s not coincidental. With the power of the right, influencers and trad-wife platforms. Walk into Target and you see the prairie dresses, and gingham is back in style, and this whole farmhouse aesthetic that is tapping into this imagined sense of who we are as Americanss, and it’s a very selective sense.
It also is, I should say, a very white understanding of America and American history [00:54:00]. It centers settler colonialists, if you will, makes them the heroes in the story, and it is a tradition that is widely celebrated by white Americans, whereas people of color are seen as side characters or as people that have to be pushed off the land.
Or in the case of how this plays out in the post-World War II era and the rejection of New Deal liberalism, white industriousness is set against Black dependency. And you see this come out very clearly in anti-welfare rhetoric advertisements. Welfare recipients are always depicted as Black, as people who are not working hard, who are not tapping into this individualistic ethos that has made America so great.
So it is extremely racialized. In fact, as I’m saying this, I’m thinking about—I don’t know if you caught it recently—was it Sarah Huckabee Sanders who made this mistake in a campaign ad to talk about cutting welfare and encouraging responsibility. But the person pictured as the lazy welfare recipient was a white man.
That is not allowed. It has to be a person of color and ideally a Black woman. The quote-unquote “welfare queen.” And she was being castigated by those on the right. How dare you present a white man as a, in their words, “welfare queen.” Because this, we know, is supposed to be coded Black.
And so there are racial undertones to all of this racial coding that is just beneath the surface.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah, that’s a great illustration. And it does really also show that they don’t like it when their own values are applied to them. And of course, just from a realism standpoint, Arkansas is one of the states [00:56:00] with a very small Black population. So if you’re gonna show an average Arkansan, it’s going to be a white person.
DU MEZ: The vast majority of their welfare recipients do happen to be white in that state. It was accurate, but it conflicted with the ideology, with the mythology, and therefore it was deeply problematic, if not unforgivable.
How Christian media made conservatism the default
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. All right, well then let’s fast-forward a bit further with the development of mass culture Christian media. And you had a... I think one of the biggest, promulgators of that was a chain that doesn’t exist anymore, like LifeWay Christian Stores, which was owned by the Southern Baptist Convention.
And a lot of this popular culture that did arise, like this was how the other forms of Christianity were supplanted, in terms of branding for many Americans. So such that a lot of Americans, when they think of Christian, and you see this now in the Texas Senate race, and a lot of other ones this year where the idea of Christian is right-wing Republican.
It’s not anything else and it never was anything else. They’re so good at branding themselves, and they’re so good at saying, “Well, our values are not political. Our values are eternal truths. They’re not revisionist. This is just how it’s always been, and it’s how human nature is.”
DU MEZ: Absolutely. You said that so well. And evangelicals have always been entrepreneurial. And I talk about particular traditions of holiness evangelicalism and Keswick theology, particular holiness theology that is especially evangelistic. They literally define it as sin if you are not [00:58:00] actively evangelizing.
And they are also quick to realize the opportunities of the market, of capitalism. What better way to spread your message than to get people to pay for it themselves? You can really scale things up. And so I talk about Dwight Moody and his publishing company in the 19th century, and how he’s very clear that there is no contradiction between evangelism, Christianity, and capitalism.
In fact, it’s best to bring them all together. You get people to pay for their own evangelization. You get more money, so you can evangelize more people and make more money. It’s this perfect system. And you see that really take hold in the 20th century in the post-World War II era. That’s where you see this huge growth in Christian publishing.
And you have the rise of Christian bookstores. So there are stores scattered across the entire country where you walk in that door, and you know every single thing in that store is safe Christian, approved for the whole family. Now, the Southern Baptist Convention runs a lot of these bookstores. They are some of the key publishers, and so you can see how their teachings are then spread throughout the country. Christian radio, the same thing. It grows into this massive powerhouse. In fact, I was just on a state NPR station or state public radio station last week, and afterwards talking with the producer, and she said, “I actually grew up evangelical, so I know, and I’ve paid attention that in this state and in this capital city in this state, the Christian radio station actually has a much bigger reach than our public radio station.
And people in public radio have no clue.” But in Christian radio, and it blankets the country, and because of consolidation, these two are largely coming from just two or three sources, conservative [01:00:00] theology, conservative politics. So all the Jesus music, if you wanna hear Jesus music out there is going to come, with the exception of some small Catholic stations, gonna come wrapped up in conservative, right-wing political messaging.
It’s going to be subtle, but it’s going to be there. If you are an artist and you come out as a Democrat, good luck getting played on Christian radio. It is not going to happen. If you have a different view, say, on LGBTQ or even on feminism or on foreign policy, that’s going to make things very difficult for you.
You will not get picked up by a Christian label. You’re not gonna get airtime on Christian radio. So over time, we see how this does start to present a version of Christianity as the only version of Christianity. This is certainly what people inside those spaces believe. Most evangelicals, by the way, do not define themselves as evangelicals.
They define themselves simply as Bible-believing Christians. The default. We are the faithful Christians. But now what we see is outside those spaces, the public face of American Christianity is almost always that one particular strain, conservative evangelical. And it started inside these spaces, and for a while, it remained largely invisible to Americans outside of these spaces.
If you didn’t listen to Christian radio, if you didn’t walk into a Christian bookstore, you might not know that any of this exists. Christian bestsellers were not included on The New York Times bestseller list ‘cause The New York Times knew their audience wouldn’t read those things, so they didn’t—why even include them?—which meant they remained largely invisible.
Until the 1980s, 1990s, you start to see this spillover. Secular bookstores start to carry Christian titles. Walmart, Target start to carry Christian products. And then of course, we have Amazon where everything’s available, [01:02:00] and all of a sudden you have now this mass distribution of products coming out of this conservative subculture.
And that’s the era that we’re in today. Reality television, like you said, trad wives, these products, Hobby Lobby, Altar’d State, Joanna Gaines, all of these are coming from a particular space, but being consumed by Americans across the political spectrum.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. And they don’t have any idea that they’re...
DU MEZ: Many do not.
Women who challenged evangelical gatekeepers—and why young women leave
SHEFFIELD: A lot of them. So, all right. Well, let’s maybe end here looking at the last part of the book and the conflicts that we’re seeing now that are really bubbling up within, right-wing Christian women’s spaces.
Because one of the things that also happened, during the intervening time here is the sexual revolution. And so not only did you have real-life pressures or realizations for women that it’s okay to have casual sex, it’s okay to have a job.
It’s good to have a college education, and all these things that non-right-wing Christian women were having and nice things for themselves, financial independence, no more shame about sexuality. And so these things have really been pressuring a lot of this right-wing Christian women’s culture and submission to husbands and not wanting to work.
These in some way, it’s, harder in some sense because you do have to take care of yourself, ironically, which they don’t... Supposedly they want you to do that but not if you’re a woman who wants a job. But there’s a lot of these [01:04:00] figures like Lauren Southern or some of these other women who they really tried to live what they were told would help them.
And it didn’t work. And some of them were much more upfront about it and were censored for it. Rachel Held Evans is a good example.
DU MEZ: Yeah, it is an interesting story because in conservative Christian spaces, you needed women to be on the front lines of selling this worldview to other Christian women. It’s not a good look to have men over and over telling you need to submit to your husbands. They do it too, but to really sell the message, you need women themselves who say, “This is your path to happiness.
Trust me.” “This is what God’s calling you to do.” So you have this explosion of women’s ministries, messages and products designed just for women inside these spaces, speakers, huge conferences, sometimes filling stadiums, like women like Beth Moore, women who would come and embrace this message.
They’d learn about Jesus, and they’d learn about what they were supposed to do to be faithful Christian women. Well, then you have the internet. And for a while, this seems like a just an extension of the women’s ministry world. Any woman, now, you don’t have to be a women’s ministry leader. You don’t have to be the wife of a prominent pastor.
You can just be a good writer and start a blog, and conservative women will find you and you can minister to them. You can spread these teachings, and it seems for a while like a good thing. But then what happens is these women start to question.
They...
SHEFFIELD: Ah, here.
DU MEZ: Rachel Held Evans, Sarah Bessey, Nadia Bolz-Weber, ultimately women like Jen Hatmaker—she would be another great example here.
And ultimately even somebody like Beth Moore, who ends up, by 2016 chiding fellow evangelicals for supporting a man like Donald Trump.
She chides them for the idolatry [01:06:00] of Christian nationalism. She calls out evangelicals for not dealing with abuse in their own churches. And all of these women are seen, and rightly so, as a real threat to conservative evangelical gatekeepers. And they had, by that time, huge platforms. And so in the 2010s and up to the present, you see this battle to suppress the power and cancel some of these women who had gained massive platforms, first, in many cases, by following all the rules.
And then they had this power, they had the platform, so when they started to question the rules, they were seen, and rightly so, as real threats. But there was a significant backlash, and somebody like Beth Moore, the most powerful and beloved woman in the Southern Baptist Convention, probably person in the Southern Baptist Convention, was pushed out of the SBC.
She used to fill stadiums with her ministry events. Now she could fill a sanctuary. She had to shrink down her ministry, and she was made to pay the price. We see that over and over again. So the battle is ongoing. You have women who are dissenters from within but you also have efforts to suppress.
Meanwhile, you’ll see women from within who are saying the right things, who are defending the system, who are promoting the ideology. Those are the ones who are being lifted up, and you see money funneled into these spaces, and those are the platforms that are being supported right now.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and it’s interesting to think about this though, because the way that religion in general has transpired as a public cultural phenomenon a lot of men, especially right-leaning men, are leaving religion such that a [01:08:00] lot of the actual congregational spaces, they’re dominated by women.
Numerically it’s women who are there but also women can’t do any of the leadership positions. So So
These
Congregations are just in a real conundrum, because the only people who want to buy into it are older women. And then, on the top of that is that younger women, this current young generation of women, this is the first generation of people where the women are more secular than the men.
And so now the it’s like the foundation is falling out from the bottom of these groups. And in a lot of ways they don’t see that.
DU MEZ: Yeah. We’re seeing some really interesting trends and as you say, women have outnumbered men in the vast majority of American churches since the late 17th century, actually. So from time to time, you’ll hear, the feminization of American Christianity, but in truth, we’ve seen that consistently throughout almost all of American history.
But only recently, we are seeing young women, walk away. And so that’s the interesting new trend. In conservative spaces, you’ll often see this presented as an influx of conservative young men into conservative churches. There’s some evidence for that on a small scale, but it’s not a huge trend because from both women and men in a kind of across all the data that we have we see an exiting.
This is the growth of the nones, N-O-N-E-S, of people just leaving church altogether. But what we do see, which is very interesting, is young women are leaving at greater rates than young men are right now. And I think there’s a lot of theories as to why that might be. But we could certainly look, I think, to the recent, rhetoric [01:10:00] around gender, and increasingly restrictive rhetoric around what a Christian woman ought to do or is allowed to do.
In conservative spaces like Turning Point USA’s Women’s Summit, we now have women who are talking about “Don’t go to college, get married young, have more children than you can afford.” Now this is a recipe for a grueling life, for women, and also you don’t need the 19th Amendment.
So this real regression, and apparently a generation of young women is not finding that appealing. And if that is what is branded as Christianity, which in fact it is in many of these right-wing Christian spaces, the only way to be a good Christian woman is to embrace all of this, it’s not a huge mystery that a number of women today, young women or older women, would say, “I don’t want any of that.”
Demographic decline and the turn against democracy
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, it’s interesting to consider that as this demographic crisis is going to continue and only get worse because your analysis of the doctrinal trends for the population is absolutely right is that it may end up really transforming American Christianity in some sense because the only people who will want to go to church will be Hispanics, Black Americans and some women.
And white people in general, they also have had a larger secularization rate compared to Black Americans, Hispanic Americans. So there’s basically all the demographics that this culture of white Christian patriarchal culture, all the groups that they’ve historically hated will be the only ones who [01:12:00] want to go to their congregations, and you’re gonna have to do something to accommodate them.
DU MEZ: Well, I think that one way of understanding some of these trends is actually bringing this exodus narrative together with the rise of a more militant Christian nationalism. Because conservative Christian leaders were keenly aware of these demographic shifts.
Going back to the first decade of the 2000s, we have what sociologist Robert P. Jones has called the end of white Christian America. That white Christians are no longer in the majority. That set off alarm bells for white Christians. And then we had the election of the first Black president, Barack Obama.
Excuse me, Barack Hussein Obama. A lot of conservative evangelicals really pushed the lies that “he’s Muslim, he’s not American.” They caught on really well in evangelical spaces. Franklin Graham was a key proponent of some of these conspiracies. And then you had the Obergefell decision, which signaled to them.
They had lost the culture in this cultural sea change.
So they no longer had the numbers. They no longer had the White House, and they had lost the culture wars, and that sense of lost power, lost status, helped fuel radicalism, helped fuel the election of Donald Trump in 2016, and continues to fuel this extremist political agenda because it is clear to them, things like voter suppression, the erosion of our democratic norms.
If you look at survey data, you’ll see conservative white evangelicals across the board on a host of issues are the most supportive of the erosion of our democracy because they know [01:14:00] that they no longer have the numbers, and looking into the future, will not have the numbers to impose their will on society solely through democratic means.
And that has really helped enhance the appeal of a leader like Donald Trump, who also has little interest in maintaining democratic norms and limitations on his power.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, and it will certainly be interesting to see where things end up.
DU MEZ: We will see.
SHEFFIELD: People really can make a difference in this though. It’s important because a lot of people who are trapped in these cultures, they do feel trapped, and they do feel awful about their situation, but they can’t ever talk about it.
And so they’re never gonna tell you if you’re someone outside of it. They’re never gonna tell you that generally speaking. So it’s important to be there for them as somebody they can be honest with because that’s really the core feature of this culture is dishonesty and self-repression.
And so if you can be there just... And sometimes it can be hard talking to people who have a lot of these real anti-democratic values. So I understand if you don’t wanna do that. But sometimes just being a lived example of somebody who practices either a more compassionate and rational form of Christianity or somebody who isn’t religious at all, or some other religion.
Just simply being an example of a good person who is open and free, that can really mean a lot to someone in a moment of...
Finding a way out of systems of control
DU MEZ: It absolutely does. And in the book, at the end of the book, I bring in the voices of women who did find ways to leave, and that’s exactly what a woman named [01:16:00] Christie says, and I include her story at the end of the book, where she says what helped her leave these high-control religious spaces was simply the patience of people who came alongside her and, in her case, showed her that there was another way to be Christian.
And it wasn’t condemnation, it wasn’t rational argument, it wasn’t saying, “You’re living lies.” It was just that patient refusal to judge on a personal level. We can make political judgments, but continuing to walk alongside her and giving her grace, and it was that grace and friendship and patience that provided her the way out.
And it can take years in some cases. But that’s really what it takes on a personal level. And today, we do have a growing movement that identifies as ex-vangelical or leaving these conservative spaces, and they have podcasts and they have blogs, and they have platforms, and there are memoirs coming out that are available now.
And so I think people who are on the other side of this are now speaking out about those dynamics. And if all of this, if you’re from far outside, not even familiar with this, pick up a memoir, listen to a podcast from people talking about what it was like on the inside, what attracted them to it and why it was so hard to leave, but how they ultimately were able to find a better understanding of their own identity and what it was like to live with others, even across a difference.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. Well, so what did this book mean to you as a white Christian woman, writing it? What did it mean to you in the writing about it and the thinking about it? Because I’m sure that’s something you thought about.
DU MEZ: So I’m gonna tell you, I do have to hop off at 2:30 sharp ‘cause I have another interview. I’m booked solid all day, so [01:18:00] I’ll... This is a great... Okay.
For me, writing this, it was led by curiosity. I’ve inhabited these spaces. I was never fully inside this world, but I read the Christian novels.
I listened to the Christian music. I bought the Precious Moments figurines. I grew up at least with a foot in this culture, and as a cultural historian, I wanted to figure out what was going on here. I wanted to have a deeper understanding, not just about the products themselves, but ultimately, this book ended up being about systems of manipulation and control.
And I learned things in the research from this book that absolutely blew my mind in how these systems were deliberately constructed and perpetuated, and how people are drawn into them and held inside of them, not just through coercion, but also through promise of reward. And so what this book has meant to me, honestly, it ends in a dark place, I think it’s fair to say, by exposing these systems of manipulation and control, not just in the lives of Christian women, but now we can see patterns on a national level.
We can see some of these patterns in the Republican Party in the MAGA movement. But importantly, I think that once you see how these systems were made, once you see the logic, once you have eyes to see how all of this works, you can’t unsee it. And that in and of itself, that knowledge does give you power.
It gives you power over the system. It gives you power to decide if you want to push back, to know what it was that you were a part of, and power to imagine a different way forward. So even though the book goes into some dark places, I think ultimately you have to go there if you want to know how to fight back against these systems of manipulation and control.
SHEFFIELD: Yeah. All right. Well, [01:20:00] the book is Live, Laugh, Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. Kristin Kobes Du Mez, thank you for being here.
DU MEZ: Thank you so much for having me.
SHEFFIELD: All right, so that is the program for today. I appreciate you joining me for the conversation. And you can always get more if you go to theoryofchange.show, where we have the video, audio, and transcript of all the episodes. And thanks to everybody who is a paid subscribing member. You also have unlimited access to the archives, and I really thank you for your support.
It’s very helpful in this media economy. We have to rely on the people to help us out, independent content creators. So thank you so much if you are able to become a paid subscribing member. And I also have a GoFundMe, which is linked in the episode show notes as well, if you can support over that way if that’s your preference.
Thanks so much. I’ll catch you next time. [01:22:00]











